
The Philadelphia Phillies boast one of MLB’s top rotations, but after how the 2024 season concluded, an upgrade might be in order. While significant changes to their rotation are unlikely this winter, Spencer Turnbull’s departure to free agency opens up an intriguing opportunity.
A potential high-impact signing could replace Turnbull and provide the Phillies with a surefire Hall of Fame-caliber addition. Bleacher Report’s Joel Reuter recently suggested one such move: “The Atlanta Braves bought low on an aging Chris Sale last offseason, hoping he could hold down the No. 5 starter job, and he ended up winning National League Cy Young honors,” Reuter wrote. “The Phillies could take a similar approach with Max Scherzer, targeting him on a one-year deal and giving him a chance to pitch for a World Series contender in the twilight of his Hall of Fame career.”
Such a signing could elevate the Phillies’ rotation while maintaining their championship aspirations heading into 2025.
Max Scherzer’s career numbers are nothing short of remarkable. Over 17 seasons, he has amassed a 215-111 record with a 3.16 ERA, an impressive 3,391-to-752 strikeout-to-walk ratio, a .220 batting average against, and a 1.08 WHIP. Despite recent injury struggles, the three-time Cy Young winner is ready for another shot at success.
According to Spotrac, Scherzer could be signed for an estimated $15.3 million—a bargain for a future Hall of Famer. While he turns 41 next July, his pedigree is undeniable. Adding Scherzer would give the Phillies an experienced postseason veteran who knows what it takes to win, all without the burden of a long-term financial commitment.
As a two-time World Series champion, Scherzer brings invaluable knowledge of high-pressure situations. For a Phillies team that has continually fallen short of claiming their third title, signing him could be the move to finally push them over the edge. Acting quickly may be key before another contender seizes the opportunity.